The Truth About Social Media Our Students Don’t Know

If we’re going to disciple the next generation well, we should tell them the truth—not just about God, but also about the world they live in. This includes but is not limited to the online realm. Especially the illusionary world of social media.

From the outset, social media isn’t neutral. It’s not just a fun tool. It’s not just a way to stay connected. It’s not even primarily about content.

It’s about formation.

Start with Identity, Not Technology

Before we talk algorithms, screen time limits, or mental health problems from social media usage, we would be wise to talk to our students about their identity in Christ. I believe social media creates identity crises in our young people due to the nature of this technology.

Students today are being constantly discipled by what they see online. Our first social media battle is not about their online behavior; it’s more deeply connected to the belief about who they are.

Social media tells them:

• You are what you look like
• You are what people say about you
• You are what gets the most likes

Scripture tells them:

• You are made in the image of God
• You have inherent dignity and worth
• Your value is not earned—it is given to you by Christ

If we skip this step, everything else becomes behavior management instead of spiritual formation.

The Social Media Illusion

Social media doesn’t show reality—it curates it.

Students consume highlight reels disguised as everyday life. What looks spontaneous is staged. What looks effortless is edited.

And here’s the underlying danger:

Students don’t just compare someone else’s highlight reel to reality—they compare it to their behind-the-scenes.

This illusion creates in our students:

• Insecurity
• Envy
• Anxiety
• Depression
• A distorted view of normal life
• A disconnect from reality

As leaders, we must help them see clearly:
Much of what they scroll through is not real life—it’s an illusion.

Algorithms: The Hidden Engine

Most students (and many adults) have no idea how social media works.

The algorithms that control your feeds are not designed for connection—it’s designed for consumption.

A few key realities we need to teach young people:

• Social media is a business
• The user is not in control
• The technology modifies behavior

Algorithms collect user data to:

• Keep you watching or scrolling
• Makes you emotionally react to content
• Keeps you coming back (this technology is addictive by design)

As the algorithms build data on user interaction, it feeds our students more to keep them hooked.

This means:

• Students are not in control of what they see
• Their attention spans are being shaped
• They are being psychologically manipulated.

This is not accidental—it’s engineered.

Why This Matters for Discipleship

If we ignore how social media works, we leave students vulnerable to being discipled by it instead of by Christ. Social media exposes students to a variety of dangers.

We cannot afford to treat this as a side issue.

Social media:

• Shapes identity
• Influences beliefs
• Forms habits
• Competes for attention
• Alters behavior
• Causes mental health issues
• Devalues truth

And ultimately, it affects how students:

• Engage with God
• Relate to others
• Understand reality

A Pastoral Challenge

Parents and pastors don’t need to panic—but we do need to engage.

Ask:

• Do my students understand how social media is shaping them?
• Have I helped them think critically about what they consume?
• Am I discipling them in their digital lives—or ignoring it?
• Am I showing them their true idenity in Jesus?

Because if we don’t step in here, social media will be glad to take over their spiritual formation.

Don’t miss Jeremy’s next post. Enter your email below to have it delivered straight to your inbox: